| |
DL1FDF > QRP 20.04.98 23:07l 89 Lines 3986 Bytes #-10438 (0) @ WW
BID : 204807DB0VFK
Read: DG6MS GUEST
Subj: SIERRA PWR MODS 4
Path: DB0ZKA<DB0LX<DB0CZ<DB0GE<DB0GV<DB0EAM<DL0EAM<DB0VFK
Sent: 980420/2040z @:DB0VFK.#HES.DEU.EU [JO41SG TheBox DG5FAU] $:204807DB0VFK
de DL1FDF @ DB0VFK.#HES.DEU.EU (Steve)
to QRP @ WW
Date: Sat, 21 Mar 1998 23:40:53 -0800
From: "L.Svec,W.Burdick" <svecbrdk@well.com>
To: qrp-l@Lehigh.EDU
Cc: ddm@datatamers.com, qrpbob@datatamers.com, ki6ds@telis.org,
wager@juno.com, erics@cruzio.com
Subject: [6564] SM caps -- not! And a bit on the Sierra design...
Message-ID: <v03102800b13a67f09216@[206.169.228.74]>
Mime-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
Folks,
The NPO ceramic and C0G caps I specified for the Wilderness Sierra have a
very decent dissipation factor, measured at .005 to .001, which
translates to a Q of 200 to 1000. Yes, S.M. caps are more consistent:
in my experience, usually around Q=700+.
C0G-rating caps are typically better than NPO ceramic disc.
However, even a capacitor whose Q is at the "low" end of this range (200)
is *not* going to make a noticeable dent in the output power, as Dave
Fitfield reminded us recently. Just to convince myself of this, I have
on many occasions replaced 5% NPO or C0G caps with S.M. and -- true enough
--
no difference in power output. (Exception: you may just happen to find
a cap that is closer to the optimal value for a particular filter.)
Now I *did* use some low-Q caps on the original NorCal (club project)
Sierra; they were 10%, high-K units, definitely to be avoided as they
have Q's as low as 40 and wider capacitance tolerance. This was my mistake,
corrected on the very first Wilderness run. Always stick with 5%, NPO
or C0G, and watch the voltage rating.
If you have a Sierra and want more power output, you have a few choices.
You might follow my suggestions in the manual, especially the two
easiest:
(1) increase supply voltage; (2) replace the output choke with a 2:1
transformer wound on the same core. You can also experimentally stretch
or squeeze toroid windings in the low-pass filters--just check your work
with a spectrum analyzer, because you may compromise the return loss or
spectral purity of the signal by doing this.
(On the other hand, you may make it better.
Toroids seem to have as much as a 10% swing in permeability,
and that's *before* everyone winds them their own way :)
As I've pointed out before, the Sierra is designed to meet cost, size,
and ease-of-construction goals, and therefore does not have a complicated
transmit strip. I designed for the 2-3 watt level at 20 meters. Power
output is usually higher than this on the lower bands, lower on the
higher bands.
Of course the S/N ratio is typically higher on the high bands
(because they're usually quieter), so you might consider the lower power
and reduced current drain as a feature for portable operation :)
But if you really want a 5-watts-on-all-bands Sierra with no tweaking,
you'll have to re-design the transmit strip. I have built such a strip
on a protoboard; it takes about 30 to 40% more parts than the existing
transmitter design. (It won't fit in the same space without doing
something I have sworn NEVER to do to the kit builders of the world,
some of whom have marginal vision, and that's use surface-mount parts.)
Basically, what it requires is more gain stages, each with feedback,
resulting in a more "level" frequency response from 2-30Mhz. It's also
helpful to include ALC or some way of automatically controlling power
output in response to load or drive changes. You also have to be very
careful not to cause problems with excess in-the-box radiation near
sensitive circuits. Again, this would be dificult at the Sierra'a size
and price point; you'd probably have to add either a small additional PCB or
some shielding.
Have fun,
waYne,
N6KR
n6kr@elecraft.com
-- or --
svecbrdk@well.com
--
qsp de dl1fdf
=========================================================================
AX25: dl1fdf@db0vfk.#hes.deu.eu | dl-qrp-ag GM | g-qrp 8769| qrp-l 252
e-mail: bauer@student.uni-kassel.de | 72 de steve DL1FDF -- DL/VY1QRP
=========================================================================
Read previous mail | Read next mail
| |