| |
ZL3AI > APRDIG 20.12.00 15:59l 194 Lines 7722 Bytes #999 (0) @ WW
BID : 35147_ZL3AI
Read: GUEST
Subj: TAPR Digest, Dec 18, 7/10
Path: DB0ABH<DB0RGB<OK0PPL<OK0PHL<OK0PBB<OK0PAB<HA5OB<HA3PG<PP5BLU<PY3KW<
ZL2TZE<ZL2TZE<ZL2WA<ZL2BAU<ZL3VML
Sent: 001218/2335Z @:ZL3VML.#80.NZL.OC #:51013 [Chch-NZ] FBB7.00g25 $:35147_ZL3
From: ZL3AI@ZL3VML.#80.NZL.OC
To : APRDIG@WW
Date: Mon, 18 Dec 2000 17:19:08 -0600
X-Message-Number: 34
At 03:37 PM 12/18/00, Eric Cuthbert wrote:
>Something also has to be said for finding, fixing and resolving ones own
>problems. It might be easier to buy or build something new but you will
>appreciate your equipment more if you know how to fix or have fixed it
>yourself. As well as learn something new. That is part of our hobby!
And it also goes to show that you can't please anyone on the SIG. I have
taken severe heat on this SIG in the past for not promoting Kit Building
and when I do, it makes someone unhappy.
Having owned my share of older TNC's as well as doing a good amount of
troubleshooting other people's TNC's, I have a pretty keen insight of the
operation and construction of TAPR-1 and TAPR-2 clones. These older TNC's
become less and less reliable as they age, and you can spend a great deal
of time troubleshooting and repairing them only to have a still-balky 15
year-old TNC. We've had many years to refine TNC technology and a KPC-3
plus works much better than a NEW HD-4040 ever did.
The "learning something new" argument is a tired one. And the only thing
you'll learn to appreciate after working on an HD-4040 is that they don't
make TNC's this way anymore. Working on a discrete component circuit board
TNC from 15 years ago, doesn't teach us anything new. Most of here know a
little bit about electronics already and how to do basic diagnosis and
soldering of these components. Earl also pointed out he has absolutely
no documentation on this TNC.
On the other hand - retiring this HD-4040 and replacing with the KISS-mode
TNC kit featured in the November 2000 issue of QST has plenty of
benifits. It's a modern IC design with a minimum of discrete
components. It's based on a PIC chip. PICs are modern and
microcontrollers like this are the hottest thing to hit the electronics
hobby market ever. Not everyone has yet done a project with them. So
indeed, you might learn something new there. The new KISS-mode TNC is
small and uses very little power. Ever seen and HD-4040? It's big bulky
and runs on 120 volts AC (it has an internal power supply!). The
KISS-mode TNC is designed to work with GPS's and APRS in particular - the
HD-4040 is not.
I also take issue with fixing it and giving it to a newbie ham. First-off
if you give a new ham something old and prone to breaking - especially with
no documentation, you'll still be the one supporting it. Also, if you
want someone to stay with a hobby you need to be reasonably sure to
guarantee their success. Giving someone a 15 year-old TNC that locks up
in TX or stops responding or any of the other quirks that 15 year-old
TNC's exhibit is not going to give someone new a favorable impression of
packet. Nor is he going to make any friends when the TNC locks up in
transmit on 144.39 Mhz.
If I were to take up scuba diving I would hope my mentor wouldn't give me
his 15 year-old respirator that had a tendency to "stick closed" every now
and then...
Better to mentor a ham in building or buying something new (or reasonably
new) that will work as advertised and has some association with more
current equipment.
But it's ultimately Earl's decision. Mine is just an opinion. :)
73,
Mark
KC7BXS
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: RE: 9600
From: "Robert Donnell" <kd7nm@pugetsound.net>
Date: Mon, 18 Dec 2000 15:33:56 -0800
X-Message-Number: 35
Hi Jeff, and all,
When I worked at AEA, Alinco sent us a DR-1200TH to test. It had the same
transmit problem as the majority of radios I have tested. In fact, it was
worse than most. And Alinco didn't try to fix it. I could not recommend
the DR-1200TH to ANYONE as a radio for use on 9k6 packet. Yes, they did tie
the modulation point into the PLL, bypassing the TX audio processing, and
they also did connect directly to the demodulator. It received OK, but
trying to send much more data than a connect or ack packet would produce
errors. Alinco whimped out on this radio, trying to hack an existing design
into something it would never be. Again, for probably $0.50 in parts, they
could probably have made it work.
-----Original Message-----
From: bounce-aprssig-17768@lists.tapr.org
[mailto:bounce-aprssig-17768@lists.tapr.org]On Behalf Of Jeff Reinhardt
Sent: Monday, December 18, 2000 2:49 PM
To: TAPR APRS Special Interest Group
Subject: [aprssig] RE: 9600
Those desiring an "off the shelf" 2m 9600 bps transceiver that does the
job very well should search for an Alinco DR-1200TH data radio.
---- more deleted ----
73, Bob
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Robert Donnell, KD7NM (206) 542-7661
18828 Midvale Ave N mailto:kd7nm@pugetsound.net
Shoreline, WA 98133
Western Washington Amateur IP Address Coordinator
-----------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: 9600 Baud Cxxx
From: David VanHorn <dvanhorn@cedar.net>
Date: Mon, 18 Dec 2000 18:32:56 -0500
X-Message-Number: 36
>Selling 9600 bps equipment is not the same as it performing well. I've
>read horror stories from companies and governemnt agenices who've purchased
>"high speed" 9600 bps commercial mobile AVL and data systems only to never
>have them work as advertised.
This has a close paralell in the credit card industry.
1200 baud 212 is as fast as they've gone, because the carrier establishment
takes too long, relative to the packet sizes, at higher speeds. No real
benefit.
The general solution was to bunch up the packets, adding latency where
possible, so that the call establishment and packet overhead got small
relative to the data.
--
Where's dave? http://www.findu.com/cgi-bin/find.cgi?kc6ete-9
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: 9600 Baud
From: WA8LMF1@aol.com
Date: Mon, 18 Dec 2000 18:43:20 EST
X-Message-Number: 37
In a message dated 12/18/2000 3:26:58 PM Pacific Standard Time,
sparkfel@primenet.com writes:
<< Selling 9600 bps equipment is not the same as it performing well. I've
read horror stories from companies and governemnt agenices who've purchased
"high speed" 9600 bps commercial mobile AVL and data systems only to never
have them work as advertised. >>
Agreed! ! ! I can tell you all sorts of horror stories here in the land of
infinite multipath (southern Cal's endless mountains and canyons) about the
never-delivered promises of throughput on commercial MDT systems based on
4800 or 9600 BPS. Of two systems I personally know of, the 2400 BPS system
has about TWICE the net throughput of the "new and improved 2nd-generation"
4800 BPS one. And the management of the 4800 one is buying into mfrs claim
about how great their 9600 system is!!
Stephen H. Smith Email: wa8lmf@aol.com
Homepage: http://members.aol.com/wa8lmf
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------
| Radio Communications Systems Personal Computers
| Consulting and Systems Integration
| GPS Custom Mapping & Radio Coverage Surveys
| File Conversions MS-Windows Setups VISCII Fonts
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: 9600 Baud
From: David VanHorn <dvanhorn@cedar.net>
Date: Mon, 18 Dec 2000 18:56:04 -0500
X-Message-Number: 38
Read previous mail | Read next mail
| |