| |
ZL3AI > APRS 14.10.00 16:36l 214 Lines 7757 Bytes #999 (0) @ WW
BID : 33955_ZL3AI
Read: GUEST
Subj: TAPR Digest, Oct 11, 5/8
Path: DB0MRW<DB0ERF<DB0ROF<DB0AIS<DB0ZDF<DB0GE<LX0PAC<LX0HST<HA3PG<WB0TAX<
VK3BBS<VK2CZR<VK2GJB<ZL2TZE<ZL2TZE<ZL2WA<ZL2TCX<ZL2BAU<ZL3VML
Sent: 001012/1052Z @:ZL3VML.#80.NZL.OC #:43224 [Chch-NZ] FBB7.00g25 $:33955_ZL3
From: ZL3AI@ZL3VML.#80.NZL.OC
To : APRS@WW
Going from 5w to 15 watts does give you a 3 to 1 statistical advantage
for a mobile station.!
Hummmh... I think I will call this "Bob's law of APRS propogation..."
<grin>
Also, most people assume that mobile PACKET is like voice. Good for 30
miles to the nearest voice repeater. Wrong! We communicate all the time
with voice with mobile flutter, picketfencing, noise, dropouts, and are
quite happy with it. But anything will kill a packet. My experience
there is that if the range of a repeater is 30 miles for voice, then the
same site may support packet only 15 miles or less reliably. (covers only
25% of the same area). Thus you need 4 or more times as many digis to
cover the same areas (for mobiles) as we do for voice... or somthing like
that...
de WB4APR
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Balloon Race
From: Steve Dimse <k4hg@tapr.org>
Date: Wed, 11 Oct 2000 12:20:35 -0400
X-Message-Number: 17
The Americas Challenge balloon race is well underway, though it looks
like perhaps half of the entrants never got airborne (or their trackers
are defunct). You can follow the action at a special web page on findu:
http://www.findu.com/cgi-bin/aibf.cgi
This is a very cool use of APRS!
Steve K4HG
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: Looking for inexpensive APRS tracker
From: Jeff King <jeff@aerodata.net>
Date: Wed, 11 Oct 2000 12:27:26 -0400
X-Message-Number: 18
Since no-one corrected the technical inaccuracies here....
Mark Fellhauer wrote:
> At 12:04 AM 10/10/00, Byon Garrabrant wrote:
>
> >The
> >trackers included a 5W 12V 2M ADI AT-201 ($115), a Rand
> >McNally GPS ($75), a TinyTrak ($25), a mag mount quarter wave, a
> >cig lighter plug, audio cables, and a small plastic case.
>
> ---------------------------------
>
> 5 watt HT.
The TinyTrak can be used with any power rig.
> TinyTrak is a kit, which requires soldering and
> programming. It is also a TX only option with no provision to hold-off
> transmit on a busy channel.
It has a hold off circuit. Take a look at the file tinytrakschematic.gif in:
http://www.byonics.com/tinytrak/tinytrak.zip
> The TinyTrak has a place in APRS, but it's not a
> good solution for the novice APRS'er. 5 watts just doesn't cut it as a
> mobile tracker in all but the best of situations.
The TinyTrak is a device similar to a MIC-E or PIC-E. It has no radio built
in, and can be used with any power radio as I mentioned earlier. One is not
the other, just because one person finds 5 watts enough for the job doesn't
mean you can't run your 100+ watt aprs tracker.
-Jeff
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: APRS Violates Laws of Physics
From: Jeff King <jeff@aerodata.net>
Date: Wed, 11 Oct 2000 12:41:50 -0400
X-Message-Number: 19
Bob Bruninga wrote:
>
> Mark F. said:..... From my unscientific tests I have found that
> > >going from five watts with an HT to a 15 watt mobile quadruples the
> > >number of successful digipeats in a typical RF environment.
> Going from 5w to 15 watts does give you a 3 to 1 statistical advantage
> for a mobile station.!
I think actually about 4-5db advantage, less then one S unit. The problem
with most "HT stations" is they end up using HT type antennas coupled with
the fact the front ends typically leave alot to be desired. From a power
level, its just not that much difference.... certainly a decent antenna
could (almost) make up the difference. There is alot more to radio then
just running alot of watts (not directed at you Bob.... your article in the
1980's "learning from cellular" was a reference for me and our packet club).
Now, what you are referring to is called "the digital brickwall" and once
you hit it, that few DB can make a difference. Yet another reason we should
avoid long packets on APRS (NMEA strings) as the
bigger the target, the better the chance a dropout will kill the entire packet.
With deep flutter (20db or more), that 4 db advantage won't mean much. Plus,
evenwith no flutter, but a weak signal, BER eventually does catch up to you
with big
packets. Do the math.
But there is more to it then
that. Most repeaters are at good sites.... they are high, they have bandpass
filters on them, they know a little about RF, they basically have made a serious
enough commitment to put some equipment at a remote site. Its just not fair to
compare them to home base radios. Packet stations at high community sites must
have bandpass filters, and if near cochannel systems, even notch filters. To
make a comparison, you must compare apples to apples. Repeaters by default have
these things, and I assure you they do make a difference.
-Jeff
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: Looking for inexpensive APRS tracker
From: Peter Anderson <panderson@CenterPartners.com>
Date: Wed, 11 Oct 2000 10:48:20 -0600
X-Message-Number: 20
I was just looking for information on the best way for trackers and to have
people email me OFF the list. That is why I am reluctant to place any
questions here to this list as I have had problems in starting this email
war before. this list is, in my feeling, not for those of us who are just
starting out as APRS hobbyists. This is more of a technical list not a
beginners list. In the future I will take my mail elsewhere to avoid this
issue on this list.
Thank You
Peter, N0WRE
-----Original Message-----
From: Jeff King [mailto:jeff@aerodata.net]
Sent: Wednesday, October 11, 2000 10:06 AM
To: TAPR APRS Special Interest Group
Cc: TAPR APRS Special Interest Group; aprssig@tapr.org;
RMckni8527@aol.com
Subject: [aprssig] Re: Looking for inexpensive APRS tracker
Mark Fellhauer wrote:
> At 11:41 PM 10/10/00, RMckni8527@aol.com wrote:
> >Go forth and wire,
> >and build, and experiment, and learn. And probably save a few bucks, if
> >that's important. The Ham that can fix and wire up stuff is far more
> >valuable than someone who has to wait until Radio Shack opens up to buy a
> >replacement cable.
> I think you've missed the point. The original inquiry was a SIMPLE
> low-cost tracker. The objective of this is not kit-building. When you
buy
> a kit - you know what you are getting into.
He was talking about a TinyTrack? About as simple as they get plus a
gez-whiz
GUI config utility. Best of both worlds.
> When someone wants a tracker, they want to get on the air and transmit
> their location, not spend a weekend squinting over a PC board with burning
> flux fumes in their eyes.
A 16 year old built a TinyTrak in less then one hour with no help. I'm sure
he or
others would be happy to help out soldering a extremely simple PCB for a
small fee.
> I'm sorry, but the tenor of the "homebrew" people around here
> is reaching about the same level of zeal as the pro-code crowd.
This is off topic, but to compare the luddinite "pro-code" crowd to
homebrewers,
frankly is insulting. I think you owe a apology on this one. I'm not
suggesting
homebrewing makes sense all the time, but it's on a entirely different level
then
rabid pro-coders. The first clearly is a marketable skill, the later even
old
time ship to shore stations have now been moving away from.
> Your words: "The Ham that can fix and wire up stuff is far more
> valuable than someone who has to wait until Radio Shack opens up to buy a
> replacement cable."
>
> I think I'm gonna print that up and make banner out of it. Maybe post it
> at the next SEARC meeting. Of course I'll give you proper credit for the
> quote.
I hope your serious as its one of the better quotes on the SIG in some time.
Read previous mail | Read next mail
| |