| |
G4EBT > YL 22.02.09 22:30l 155 Lines 5386 Bytes #999 (0) @ WW
BID : 990316G4EBT
Read: GUEST
Subj: Re: Back Again (G4EBT)
Path: DB0FHN<DB0FOR<DB0MRW<DB0ERF<OK0NAG<OK0PPL<DB0RES<DK0WUE<GB7FCR
Sent: 090222/1929Z @:GB7FCR.#16.GBR.EU #:24583 [Blackpool] FBB-7.03a $:990316G4
From: G4EBT@GB7FCR.#16.GBR.EU
To : YL@WW
Grace, G6YFF wrote:-
> The reply from David G4EBT seemed very defeatist and resigned to us
> seeming to be the lowest denominator.
Thanks for reading my bull Grace, and taking the trouble to respond.
I'm not sure whether by "defeatist" you mean my comments that packet
"radio" as we knew it (as a worldwide RF network) hasn't existed for
some eight years or so.
That's a fact of life - it isn't going to change any time soon.
Or whether you mean that I said we don't have control over where
information we place in the public domain (ie in packet bulls),
much of which - whatever our own wishes, inevitably ends up on
internet.
I googled "packet radio+yl". It came back in 0.16 seconds with 13,500
references. How many of those were uploaded via packet by amateurs
believing they'd stay within the bounds of packet, I've no idea,
and I don't much care.
I mention it to illustrate the extent to which this arises.
And people really think they can put a stop to this?
In your earlier bull you had written:
>I have already emailed one web owner in Germany asking him to remove
>all of my packet messages as I do not really want my (new) identity
>compromised.
I guess that will be DB0FHN server then.
>I have been open within our community,
"Our community" is probably the least understanding bunch you could come
across, given their age, mind-set and gender. I repeat: packet is not a
normal cross section of society. (The OFCOM MORI survey in 2005 revealed
that 93% are male and 50% were over 65. Four years have elapsed since).
>but not to the whole world.
A message to packet is in reality a message to the whole world on
internet.
In my bull of 15 Feb I explained that a google of your callsign turned up
175 references. Today, a week later, I've googled it again. It's risen to
248.
I've only seen three bulls from you on packet in your new persona, so
unless you are posting messages on internet using your callsign, it's
cropping up from numerous sources with increasing regularity - 10 a day
in the last week.
Sure, you can write to the sysop at DB0FHN, but to achieve what you desire
you'd need to constantly trawl internet for references to your callsign,
flitting around like janitor, asking each poster to kindly delete all
references to you. To what end, I know not.
There's a cruel irony in a message I've just read on internet dated 29 Nov
2003 entitled "Is Internet Killing Packet"? [No it isn't - it's keeping it
alive].
So, a packet message about internet killing packet, was uploaded to a BBS
by a UK amateur using internet, referring to an article written by a UK
sysop for a UK Amateur Radio Website, pointing to the website link.
It's still there on internet - long since forgotten on packet.
http://www.db0anf.de/app/bbs/messages/show-217471G4WYW
I rest my case.
Dealing in turn with the two issues:
1) RF Packet:
Progressively from about 1998, the peak year for bulletin traffic in the
UK traffic declined markedly and more and more RF BBSs closed down, mostly
citing lack of use and lack of users making it not worthwhile to continue.
Mercifully, others sysops began to use internet to repair lost links,
and those sysops did this in *addition to*, not *instead of* providing
RF facilities. More effort, more time and more expense on the part of
those sysops, which I for one, am extremely grateful for.
They're not defeatists - quite the opposite - they're pragmatists and
realists who keep the show on the road. I'm not rejoicing in the loss
of RF BBSs, I'm simply explaining the facts as they are, not as we might
wish them to be.
Sysops such as George, G1NNB, sysop at GB7ESX, and Trevor, M1CUK sysop
at GB7FCR to name but two, have been in it for the long haul. Both offer
excellent RF facilties for those within range, and telnet for those who
aren't.
If those who dislike this development were to append their messages with
"please don't forward messages to and from me by internet - only by RF",
their messages wouldn't see the light of day.
That's the way it is.
2) Keeping packet message off internet:
As to whether it's defeatist to not be able to exercise control over where
our messages end up and who reads them, the point at which we make that
decision is when we decide to upload them.
This is no different from an on-air QSO.
If we go on air, people will be listening.
If we write a bull, somone will be reading. (We hope).
People who read stuff on packet BBSs via internet are no different.
(They can't read them on packet via RF as that needs a licence).
They can read them via internet but can't reply to them without a
licence, any more than could an SWL go on air and reply to a CQ call.
Think of them as packet SWLs.
The bottom line is:
Packet stuff is in the public domain and if we don't want that stuff
getting out there, we'd best not put it there. Not defeatist, not the
lowest common denominator - pragmatism.
I hope that's made it a bit clearer.
Every good wish in your endeavours to exercise control over cyberspace.
I hope your computer is now behaving itself Grace.
Quote of the day:
'The Woods Would Be Very Silent if Only Those Birds Sang Who Sing the
Best'
Best wishes
David, G4EBT @ GB7FCR
Cottingham, East Yorkshire.
Message timed: 18:27 on 2009-Feb-22
Message sent using WinPack-Telnet V6.70
(Registered).
Read previous mail | Read next mail
| |