OpenBCM V1.13 (Linux)

Packet Radio Mailbox

DB0FHN

[JN59NK Nuernberg]

 Login: GUEST





  
ZL3AI  > APRDIG   03.02.03 14:29l 228 Lines 9602 Bytes #999 (0) @ WW
BID : 787-ZL3AI
Read: GUEST
Subj: TAPR Digest, Jan 25, 3/4
Path: DB0FHN<DB0ZWI<DB0HST<ON0DXC<WA7V<W7NTF<WB0TAX<VK3AVE<VK3KAY<ZL2BAU<
      ZL3VML
Sent: 030129/1007Z @:ZL3VML.#80.NZL.OC #:58387 [Chch-NZ] FBB7.00i $:787-ZL3AI
From: ZL3AI@ZL3VML.#80.NZL.OC
To  : APRDIG@WW

Subject: Re: Icon for I'net-only station?
From: "Spider" <spider@rivcom.net>
Date: Sat, 25 Jan 2003 15:35:51 -0700
X-Message-Number: 20

----- Original Message -----
From: "AE5PL Lists" <HamLists@ametx.com>
To: "TAPR APRS Special Interest Group" <aprssig@lists.tapr.org>
Sent: Saturday, January 25, 2003 1:15 PM
Subject: [aprssig] Re: Icon for I'net-only station?

>Shouldn't that station use an icon that reflects what the station is
>(such as a house, hotel, etc.), not how it is connected to the APRS
>world?

No.  If I am in a hotel room, should it show Iam a hotel?  No.  If it is the
primary station for the hotel...mmmmmaybe.  What does a hotel do as a
station?
If your FCC licensed repeater was on top of a motel, would it be licensed as
a motel?  No.
If my station is in a hotel and it's acting as a digi..then is it a hotel or
a digi?  It's a digi, not a Hotel.  The "place" the station is, really
should have nothing to do with what it does.  It's function should be
identified.  The place where the station is located is indicated by it's
coordinates.
However, I think OBJECTS could fit your question.  A Hotel is an OBJECT on a
map, not a STATION.
Some are missing the point that the APRS symbols....as are being discussed,
reflect only stations.  But they don't.  They can also represent OBJECTS and
they can represent both.  An Island is an OBJECT on a map, not a station.
What does a station do as an Island? Float around in the ocean? A FIRE on a
map is an OBJECT, not a station.
It's darn near rocket science, I tell'ya! :)
---
Finally, regarding "new" icons.  Icons that aren't represented in the
specification that have been discussed need to be added to the spec.
This may be a good thing for the Bob's errata page.  However, if icons
are added, notification of such additions need to be sent to client
authors and what the actual icon is to look like needs to be posted with
the addition on the errata page.  Otherwise, you end up with a
hap-hazard implementation which could cause people to become
disenchanted with APRS.
---
Who adds them to the Specification?  Bob?

----------------------------------------------------------------------

Subject: Re: Icon for I'net-only station?
From: "AE5PL Lists" <HamLists@ametx.com>
Date: Sat, 25 Jan 2003 17:36:26 -0600
X-Message-Number: 21

>-----Original Message-----
>From: Spider [mailto:spider@rivcom.net]
>Posted At: Saturday, January 25, 2003 4:38 PM
>Subject: [aprssig] Re: Icon for I'net-only station?
>
>No.  If I am in a hotel room, should it show Iam a hotel?
>No.  If it is the primary station for the hotel...mmmmmaybe.
>What does a hotel do as a station? If your FCC licensed
>repeater was on top of a motel, would it be licensed as a
>motel?  No. If my station is in a hotel and it's acting as a
>digi..then is it a hotel or a digi?  It's a digi, not a
>Hotel.  The "place" the station is, really should have
>nothing to do with what it does.  It's function should be
>identified.  The place where the station is located is

Using the logic that your FCC license should signify what you use as an
icon, then everyone should be using icons that reflect class of license.
It has become standard practice to have the icon identify the type of
vehicle or structure that the station is operating from if there is no
other more appropriate icon to use which would show functionality.  In
your example, the digi function overrides the desire to show location
type.  The same would be true for a weather station.  The weather
function would override location type.  However, when you get into
multiple functions, then the operator chooses what is most important to
show.

BTW, when I operate from a hotel, I use the hotel icon because it best
represents that I am operating fixed portable from a hotel.  None of the
icons, today, represent how a station is broadcasting (via RF or via the
Internet).  That is what my question was referring to.  I still maintain
that icon choice is first, a decision of the operator.  What has been
recommended on this SIG and is in standard usage is to select an icon
based on station function first (digi, wx, etc.) and location type
second (car, truck, house, etc.).  IMO, I don't see a need to add a
third level of identification: RF or Internet.

>Who adds them to the Specification?  Bob?

Good question and one that begs an answer from somebody more
authoritative than myself.

73,

Pete Loveall AE5PL
pete@ae5pl.net

----------------------------------------------------------------------

Subject: Re: Icon for I'net-only station?
From: "Ronald Reams" <wa4mjf@worldnet.att.net>
Date: Sat, 25 Jan 2003 19:13:39 -0500
X-Message-Number: 22

----- Original Message -----
From: "AE5PL Lists" <HamLists@ametx.com>
To: "TAPR APRS Special Interest Group" <aprssig@lists.tapr.org>
Sent: Saturday, January 25, 2003 18:36
Subject: [aprssig] Re: Icon for I'net-only station?

BTW, when I operate from a hotel, I use the hotel icon because it best
represents that I am operating     fixed portable
                                        ^^^^^^^^^^

A portable station may be moved from one place to another, but not operated
in motion. therefore it is by definition fixed.   A mobile station operates
on the move or stopped.
BTW, you are no longer required to notify your EIC when portable for more
than 48 hours.

from a hotel.  None of the
icons, today, represent how a station is broadcasting (via RF or via the
Internet).  That is what my question was referring to.  I still maintain
that icon choice is first, a decision of the operator.  What has been
recommended on this SIG and is in standard usage is to select an icon
based on station function first (digi, wx, etc.) and location type
second (car, truck, house, etc.).  IMO, I don't see a need to add a
third level of identification: RF or Internet.

>Who adds them to the Specification?  Bob?

Good question and one that begs an answer from somebody more
authoritative than myself.

73,

Pete Loveall AE5PL
pete@ae5pl.net

----------------------------------------------------------------------

Subject: Re: Icon for I'net-only station?
From: "Ramon F. Kolb" <ramon@ieee.org>
Date: Sat, 25 Jan 2003 22:16:10 -0500
X-Message-Number: 23

>From: bounce-aprssig-24121@lists.tapr.org
[mailto:bounce-aprssig-24121@lists.tapr.org] On Behalf Of AE5PL Lists
>Sent: Saturday, January 25, 2003 15:15
>To: TAPR APRS Special Interest Group
>Subject: [aprssig] Re: Icon for I'net-only station?
>
>A callsign with no SSID shown is a station with a SSID of zero.
>Therefore, adding this to the data stream would not act as a differentiator.
>
>On the overall subject of an icon for Internet-only stations, my question
>would be "Why?".  The APRS-IS is a backbone that interconnects
>local APRS networks.  That "local" APRS network may be a station of one.
>Shouldn't that station use an icon that reflects what the station
>is (such as a house, hotel, etc.), not how it is connected to the APRS world?

For me, it's simple... I'm running PA3EUG(-0) at home as an IGATE. The fact
that it's my home is not important, the fact that it's an IGATE is, so I'm
using the "IGATE" symbol. I'm running PA3EUG-2 at work, I'net only. Just to
distinguish this instance from my home station, and to indicate why it is
that I'm I-GATING my own call (PA3EUG-2) back to RF via my own IGATE, I'd
like to put some identifyer there that either says "at work" or "I'net
only". Whichever.

I strongly think that the symbol should be determined by what the operator
thinks the station foremost is: this can be a location, a function, or
whatever. So if Steve thinks his station is foremost "on an island", let
him use the IOTA symbol. If you think that you're foremost a hotel, put a
hotel symbol. And if someone thinks his station is Foremost an I-Gate, or
an EOC, or a crashed airplane, let them use their symbols.

As for the tactical "usability" of these symbols, in small scale operations
one should either use an APRS subnet, or include only those stations that
are part of the operation. Then use your rules for icons as they fit the
situation as it occurs. There are no rights or wrongs here.

Again-- what symbol should I use for either my "QRL" or the fact that I'm
I-net only? If someone could answer for either case, I'd be happy to pick
the one I think looks prettiest :)

73s,

--Ram=F3n

Ram=F3n F. Kolb, W1/PA3EUG, Boston, MA, USA [FN42KI]
ICQ:77117744; MSNMGR:legalalien30@hotmail.com
http://kolb.webhop.org

----------------------------------------------------------------------

Subject: Easy Symbol/Capability Suggestion
From: "Ev Tupis (W2EV)" <w2ev@arrl.net>
Date: Sun, 19 Jan 2003 22:24:25 -0500
X-Message-Number: 24

With the deafening silence around a proposed addition to the protocol (the
suggested Configuration Code), I would like to offer one other quite lame
(because it still requires people to follow it) suggestion:

If your station:
o has a "Network Personality" other than as a RELAY digi
o is using an icon that is not indicative of it's "Network Personality"
o has multiple "Network Personalities"

....and you are inclined to make your station's "Network Personality" known
to others, place a "+" as an icon-overlay character (signifying "additional
capabilities") and embed info about your capabilities in your comment
field.

A quick visual scan will at least alert others to the fact that you have
"more than typical" capabilities and the info in your comment field will
remove the mystery.

Over and out.
Ev, W2EV

----------------------------------------------------------------------



Read previous mail | Read next mail


 16.11.2026 10:06:31lGo back Go up