OpenBCM V1.13 (Linux)

Packet Radio Mailbox

DB0FHN

[JN59NK Nuernberg]

 Login: GUEST





  
ZL3AI  > APRDIG   03.02.03 14:27l 212 Lines 9083 Bytes #999 (0) @ WW
BID : 748-ZL3AI
Read: GUEST
Subj: TAPR Digest, Jan 19, 1/5
Path: DB0FHN<DB0RGB<OK0PPL<RZ6HXA<SP7MGD<VK7AX<VK3AC<ZL2BAU<ZL3VML
Sent: 030123/1030Z @:ZL3VML.#80.NZL.OC #:57974 [Chch-NZ] FBB7.00i $:748-ZL3AI
From: ZL3AI@ZL3VML.#80.NZL.OC
To  : APRDIG@WW

TAPR APRS Special Interest Group Digest for Sunday, January 19, 2003.

1. Re: Next Generation TNC -- a "real" TNC, please - A Reply
2. Re: Does a tracker require receive?
3. SV: RE: Horrendously long path being advocated on APRS website...
4. Network Appliance: TNG -- Development *and* Discussion
5. Re: Next Generation TNC -- a "real" TNC, please - A Reply
6. D700 "TNC OPENING" burp
7. DFing on APRS+
8. RE: VX-150 manual
9. Re: D700 "TNC OPENING" burp
10. Re: Does a tracker require receive?
11. Re: Network Appliance: TNG -- Development *and* Discussion
12. Re: DFing on APRS+
13. Re: DFing on APRS+
14. Re: Lost Manual for Yaesu/Vertex VX-150
15. Re: Next Generation TNC -- a "real" TNC, please
16. Re: Next Generation TNC -- a "real" TNC, please
17. Re: Next Generation TNC -- a "real" TNC, please
18. Re: Next Generation TNC -- a "real" TNC, please
19. Backbone SPec
20. Re: Next Generation TNC -- a "real" TNC, please
21. Schematic Software
22. Re: Schematic Software
23. Re: DFing on APRS+
24. Re: Schematic Software
25. GPS device makes local news
26. APRS County Maps- for WINAPRS/APRSCE
27. Re: Schematic Software
28. Posted APRS+SA v2.21
29. PSR deadline coming soon!
30. RE: Schematic Software
31. Garmin3-KPC3P
32. Re: [aprsplus] Posted APRS+SA v2.21
33. Re: Network Appliance: TNG -- Development *and* Discussion
34. Re: Network Appliance: TNG -- Development *and* Discussion
35. Re: D700 "TNC OPENING" burp
36. Re: Network Appliance: TNG -- Development *and* Discussion

----------------------------------------------------------------------

Subject: Re: Next Generation TNC -- a "real" TNC, please - A Reply
From: "Darryl Smith" <Darryl@radio-active.net.au>
Date: Sun, 19 Jan 2003 21:24:59 +1100
X-Message-Number: 1

Darryl Smith wrote:

Alex <kr1st@amsat.org> wrote
>>With that said, I think we need to put this subject to bed until we have
>>something to release.
>Quite the opposite. I think we should continue discussing it. Perhaps
>someone else, who also didn't disclose his or her work is following this
>thread. You're not saying that you're afraid that competition may occur,
>are you? A lot of good ideas have been generated and I don't we should
>now dose off into a deep sleep waiting until TAPR decides to get out of
>hibernation with their project.

Realistically I think this is a bit unfair on all involved. At the
moment this is not an official TAPR project although a few TAPR board
members are on the mailing list.

I don't know what other people were doing on Christmas Day just after
coming home from church. Me, I was setting up the e-TNC mailing list.
That means that this project has only been in existance for less than a
month. I believe that we have done a lot in that time.

All I can say is that I expect that I will have results in the coming
weeks that will confirm that what we are doing is feasable technically.
After that everything depends on finding 'C' programmers who can do cool
stuff.

Darryl

---------
Darryl Smith, VK2TDS   POBox 169 Ingleburn NSW 2565 Australia
Mobile Number 0412 929 634 [+61 4 12 929 634 International] 
Darryl@radio-active.net.au | www.radio-active.net.au  

----------------------------------------------------------------------

Subject: Re: Does a tracker require receive?
From: "Cap Pennell" <cap@cruzio.com>
Date: Sun, 19 Jan 2003 02:40:40 -0800
X-Message-Number: 2

Bob WB4APR wrote:
>Any plan to improve 144.39 by finding efficient ways to gather even more
>packets over a larger area, but still then send them back out
>onto 144.39 is self defeating.  Remember, ANY 144.39 channel can only
>serve about 50 users reliably.  You can double this by going to a FULL
>DUPLEX analog repeater so that CSMA really works, but no matter how you
>cut it, there is still only 50 (maybe 100) that can be served without
>losing reliability for everyone.
>
>Beyond that you simply have to recognize that everyone else is not in your
>local network and there is no way to continue to broadcast everyone to
>everyone.  The only thing that can be done at this stage is gatewaying
>ONLY the DX data that someone wants, not just everything.
>
>This is what the APRS-IS and IGates do.  Everything goes IN , because they
>have the bandwidth, but NOTHING comes back to 144.39 anywhere, unless it
>has PURPOSE there.
<snip>

Perhaps a 144.39 station could "request" info back for a determinate period,
kind of like the new filters on port 14580?
73, Cap KE6AFE

----------------------------------------------------------------------

Subject: SV: RE: Horrendously long path being advocated on APRS website...
From: "Roger Bille" <roger.bille@telia.com>
Date: Sun, 19 Jan 2003 14:31:04 +0100
X-Message-Number: 3

Robbie wrote:
>What with all the comments here on the sig about paths, it would seem
>these stations don't know about APRSSIG, :-)

 I would say yes and no. I'm sure a number of non-US users are not aware of
APRSSig. But there is also a number of non-US users that have been
subscribing to APRSSIG but have stopped to do that. The main comments are
that APRSSIG is too US centric, a lot of messages telling how thing must be
configured and sometime there are heated debate down to personal level. You
also see messages where individuals are hang out about different things
instead of contacting that person directly of line, it could be a
misunderstanding or lack of knowledge.

 One thing to remember is that APRS is what we all make it to do - true HAM
spirit. It cannot only be one correct way. If there are users that want to
test and play with propergation, fine let them do that or if they need a
longer path too be shown on users maps. In some countries there are very few
IGATES due too high internet connection costs, you will then need long paths
to reach them.

 The last thing is that APRS outside US in many cases are not a tachtical
system. It is a position system where we have fun and enjoy experimenting
and try to do the best of it.

 My suggestion to everybody is to always remember that there might be more
than one correct answer, and this can depend on local
requirements/regulations/practicies that you might not be aware of.

 73 de sm5nrk/Roger

----------------------------------------------------------------------

Subject: Network Appliance: TNG -- Development *and* Discussion
From: "Ev Tupis (W2EV)" <w2ev@arrl.net>
Date: Sun, 19 Jan 2003 09:29:17 -0500
X-Message-Number: 4

>>A lot of good ideas have been generated and I don't we should
>>now dose off into a deep sleep waiting until TAPR decides to get out of
>>hibernation with their project.
> 
>Realistically I think this is a bit unfair on all involved.

These two points-of-view are actually pushing on the same elephant (a
reference to a story of 10 blind men describing an elephant, each touching
a different part).

Darryl seems to be talking about the development of an "engine".  Alex is
talking about open dialogue and vision sharing.  The "elephant" is the
development of something I refer to as "APRS Network Appliance: The Next
Generation".

The "X-Factor" from Alex's perspective may be wondering if what is being
developed will do anything that is being talked about... and if so... are
there any other folks here whose skills could add materially to "the
engine" that Darryl is working on.  (i.e. "Hey Darryl...would you share the
project goals with us?")

The "X-Factor" from Darryl's perspective is not wanting to start defending
something that doesn't exist yet...nor necessarily spending time distracted
from what he (and others involved in the project) sees as the things that
motivated him to start the project in the first place. (i.e. "Hey Alex,
give me a chance to get to the prototype-planning phase so I know if this
thing can be real or I simply abandon it with no fanfare or lost-face).

The "trick" is to walk the line between the two to make sure this moves
forward without anything "wrapping around the axel".  Look at Steve's findU
and Internet Stream system.  He was excited about it, he developed it...and
one day it "showed up".  He developed it in such a way that it was
"evergreen" and it continues to grow.  Steve was subscribed to the APRS
list, so he heard the "open dialogue" and probably factored some of it into
his project -- but the bottom line is that he is the one that was going to
make it work.

Likewise, Darryl is "do-ing", too.  He is subscribed to the general APRS
list and will no doubt be listening to the dialogue and taking it into
consideration as his vision gells (even asking clarifying questions as
appropriate).  Alex (and those that think similarly) is helping to shape a
vision of what they think NA:TNG should be given the way they use APRS and
the way Bob envisions APRS' advancement.

Let's not kill Darryl's spirit before the project is "out of the blocks"
(as what is happening with this short sighted thing around BEACONet-for-VHF
Contests).

I say... keep going, Darryl and let's keep talking, Alex!

Regards,
Ev Tupis, W2EV

----------------------------------------------------------------------



Read previous mail | Read next mail


 16.11.2026 12:59:42lGo back Go up