| |
ZL3AI > APRDIG 20.12.00 16:11l 197 Lines 7781 Bytes #999 (0) @ WW
BID : 35150_ZL3AI
Read: GUEST
Subj: TAPR Digest, Dec 18, 8/10
Path: DB0ABH<DB0RGB<OK0PPL<OK0PHL<OK0PBB<OK0PAB<HA5OB<HA3PG<PP5BLU<PY3KW<
ZL2TZE<ZL2TZE<ZL2WA<ZL2BAU<ZL3VML
Sent: 001219/0038Z @:ZL3VML.#80.NZL.OC #:51018 [Chch-NZ] FBB7.00g25 $:35150_ZL3
From: ZL3AI@ZL3VML.#80.NZL.OC
To : APRDIG@WW
>Agreed! ! ! I can tell you all sorts of horror stories here in the land of
>infinite multipath (southern Cal's endless mountains and canyons) about the
>never-delivered promises of throughput on commercial MDT systems based on
>4800 or 9600 BPS. Of two systems I personally know of, the 2400 BPS system
>has about TWICE the net throughput of the "new and improved 2nd-generation"
>4800 BPS one. And the management of the 4800 one is buying into mfrs claim
>about how great their 9600 system is!!
There was an ill-fated system that was supposed to deliver credit card data
in a single line of TV broadcast, at 3 MB/s.
I mentioned to the responsibles that this required PERFECT reception, which
was unlikely in downtown LA, where they wanted to deploy it, or over the
cable systems..
In the entire trial period, (30 days?) it never completed a single database
update.
It was supposed to take a couple hours or so.
Had they slowed the data rate down to something reasonable, they might have
had some success, but multipath really ate their lunch.
--
Where's dave? http://www.findu.com/cgi-bin/find.cgi?kc6ete-9
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: 9600 Baud Cxxx
From: Jeff King <jeff@aerodata.net>
Date: Mon, 18 Dec 2000 19:08:59 -0500
X-Message-Number: 39
David VanHorn wrote:
>
> >Selling 9600 bps equipment is not the same as it performing well. I've
> >read horror stories from companies and governemnt agenices who've purchased
> >"high speed" 9600 bps commercial mobile AVL and data systems only to never
> >have them work as advertised.
>
> This has a close paralell in the credit card industry.
> 1200 baud 212 is as fast as they've gone, because the carrier establishment
> takes too long, relative to the packet sizes, at higher speeds. No real
> benefit.
Dave:
That is not a fair analogy. The credit card companies use Bell 103 for the
primary
reason its cheap and robust, and the secondary reason no training overhead is
required
on the lines. The low speed is not a issue because the data packets are so
short. Regardless
of the modem used, the level one transport layer is the same. Such is not the
case with differing radios.
Now, if you where using V.29 16QSPK on packet (see my test in one of the
1991 PSR's), yes training is indeed a big issue, and these modems can take
200+ms to train up, which needs to be added to your overhead. With file
transfers, such as NOS TCP/IP, not a big deal. But for brief transactions,
a big deal.
APRS is a similar analogy to the credit card industry in that (most) of the
data frames are similar.... short and to the point. No big file transfers,
so TXD and overhead is not a big deal. As there is little additional training
time
for 9600bps GMSK, in particular when compared to Bell 202, I do not see your
analogy. Your analogy would imply we should FAVOR 9600bps APRS with well
designedradios because it reduces the transaction time, allowing more credit
cards to be
approved or in our case more stations to report posits over a given time frame.
In fact, the opposite analogy could be made in that well engineered radios
require LESS overhead, be it Bell 202 or 9600bps GMSK. This is not what we
are seeing in amateur packet radio, by and large. Another factor people
have not considered is the "CSMA black hole" long turnaround times cause.
That 50ms or 100ms the radio takes to stabilize between the time your TNC
says to key up and the time it starts to generate RF, is a "black hole" in
which other stations have no idea if you have started to transmit. Point
being, the longer the attack time is, the more chance your will get collisions
even in a perfect hidden terminal free CSMA network.
-Jeff
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: 9600 Baud
From: WA8LMF1@aol.com
Date: Mon, 18 Dec 2000 19:13:41 EST
X-Message-Number: 40
In a message dated 12/18/2000 3:59:30 PM Pacific Standard Time,
dvanhorn@cedar.net writes:
<< There was an ill-fated system that was supposed to deliver credit card data
in a single line of TV broadcast, at 3 MB/s.
I mentioned to the responsibles that this required PERFECT reception, which
was unlikely in downtown LA, where they wanted to deploy it, or over the
cable systems.. >>
Not to mention that this multipath issue is threatening to sink the entire
Digital/HDTV rollout.
It's so intolerant of multipath-induced bit-errors at the megabits-per-second
transmission rate that in about 1/3rd of randomly choosen locations in
strong-signal urban and suburban areas you get no picture at all off-the-air!
The HDTV on-air tests were done in the flat lands of suburban Maryland;
apparently no one thought about western terrain or the urban concrete canyons
of New York or Chicago!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: RE: 9600
From: Bob Nielsen <nielsen@oz.net>
Date: Mon, 18 Dec 2000 16:28:17 -0800
X-Message-Number: 41
I recall that Azden had a radio about the same time which modulated a
fixed frequency oscillator, rather than the PLL, and used a heterodyne
circuit. I never saw one, but heard that they had achieved fairly good
9600 performance, as do many of the all-mode radios which do the
modulation on a fixed oscillator.
Bob
On Mon, Dec 18, 2000 at 03:33:56PM -0800, Robert Donnell wrote:
> Hi Jeff, and all,
>
> When I worked at AEA, Alinco sent us a DR-1200TH to test. It had the same
> transmit problem as the majority of radios I have tested. In fact, it was
> worse than most. And Alinco didn't try to fix it. I could not recommend
> the DR-1200TH to ANYONE as a radio for use on 9k6 packet. Yes, they did tie
> the modulation point into the PLL, bypassing the TX audio processing, and
> they also did connect directly to the demodulator. It received OK, but
> trying to send much more data than a connect or ack packet would produce
> errors. Alinco whimped out on this radio, trying to hack an existing design
> into something it would never be. Again, for probably $0.50 in parts, they
> could probably have made it work.
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: bounce-aprssig-17768@lists.tapr.org
> [mailto:bounce-aprssig-17768@lists.tapr.org]On Behalf Of Jeff Reinhardt
> Sent: Monday, December 18, 2000 2:49 PM
> To: TAPR APRS Special Interest Group
> Subject: [aprssig] RE: 9600
>
>
> Those desiring an "off the shelf" 2m 9600 bps transceiver that does the
> job very well should search for an Alinco DR-1200TH data radio.
> ---- more deleted ----
>
> 73, Bob
>
> -----------------------------------------------------------------
> Robert Donnell, KD7NM (206) 542-7661
> 18828 Midvale Ave N mailto:kd7nm@pugetsound.net
> Shoreline, WA 98133
> Western Washington Amateur IP Address Coordinator
> -----------------------------------------------------------------
>
>
> ---
> You are currently subscribed to aprssig as: nielsen@oz.net
> To unsubscribe send a blank email to leave-aprssig-18700I@lists.tapr.org
> Questions regarding the SIG go to the SIG administrator: wa1lou@tapr.org
--
Bob Nielsen, N7XY nielsen@oz.net
Bainbridge Island, WA http://www.oz.net/~nielsen
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: 9600 Baud Cxxx
From: David VanHorn <dvanhorn@cedar.net>
Date: Mon, 18 Dec 2000 19:42:47 -0500
X-Message-Number: 42
At 07:08 PM 12/18/00 -0500, Jeff King wrote:
>
>That is not a fair analogy. The credit card companies use Bell 103 for the
primary
>reason its cheap and robust, and the secondary reason no training overhead
is required
>on the lines.
Read previous mail | Read next mail
| |