| |
ZL3AI > APRDIG 20.12.00 16:02l 244 Lines 7788 Bytes #999 (0) @ WW
BID : 35140_ZL3AI
Read: GUEST
Subj: TAPR Digest, Dec 18, 4/10
Path: DB0ABH<DB0CWS<DB0FP<DB0SON<DB0ERF<DB0MRW<DB0RGB<OK0PPL<OK0PHL<OK0PBB<
OK0PAB<HA5OB<HA3PG<PP5BLU<PY3KW<ZL2TZE<ZL2TZE<ZL2WA<ZL2BAU<ZL3VML
Sent: 001219/0014Z @:ZL3VML.#80.NZL.OC #:51015 [Chch-NZ] FBB7.00g25 $:35140_ZL3
From: ZL3AI@ZL3VML.#80.NZL.OC
To : APRDIG@WW
traffic with little noticeable affect on the existing network.
Net affect will be even more APRS stations and less traffic on 144.39.
A good thing!
This is where I'm "hoping" the Kenwood rigs work. It will be great
if they do! I'm a bit skeptical as general use here has
1500 bytes in a single packet...
Bill, WA7NWP
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: 9600 Baud Cxxx
From: Jeff King <jeff@aerodata.net>
Date: Mon, 18 Dec 2000 15:52:12 -0500
X-Message-Number: 21
Bob Bruninga wrote:
>
> On Mon, 18 Dec 2000, Jeff King corrected me...(but alas incorrectly)
>
> > > Something that USA Amateurs had refused to use (in general) even 18 years
> > > after 9600 baud TNC's were available.
> >
> > Lets look at U.S. packet history... (1200 bd) No store-bought or kit
> > TNC's were available in the U.S. AX.25 didn't exist.... The only real
> > activity was in Canada, from which these first U.S. amateurs took their
> > technology.
>
> Wrong, we in AMRAD in Washington DC had the Vancouver boards on the
> air long before 1982.
Since when is Vancouver in the United States? The guys in Montreal (Canada)
where using
AFSK 2400 baud in 1980, but I think the Vancouver board used Bell 202..
OK, even so, show me a 1982 Vancouver 9600bps TNC (on the air in 1982). While I
don't
have any conclusive proof, there where even CNC (DCC) papers titled "Where oh
where is
my high speed data" up until K9NG's paper in 1985. I don't think you had any
9600bps
stuff on the air in 1982, U.S. made or otherwise.
> It was at the SAME time that we in AMRAD were
> writing the AX.25 SPEC!
Doug never wrote AX.25 for the Vancouver board nor did it ever support it to my
knowledge. It had its own ID protocol, which used station ID's, numbers from 0
to 255
although he later extended it. By that time TAPR's TNC1 was out and the rest is
history. While AMRAD/TAPR/AMSAT may have been writing the 'spec' for AX.25,
this conversation was with regards to available equipment 18 years ago (1982).
> > In 1985 ... we had our first 9600bps modem design,
> > from K9NG. TAPR shortly picked this up as a kit later in 1985/86.
>
> OK, I was wrong. 9600bd was 15 instead of 18 years ago..
You said 9600bps TNC, implying a off the shelf device, which would put it
about 10 years ago.... my point being is that we in the U.S. had a smaller
window of
opportunity then the Europeans, relative to widespread internet adoption. This,
in
my opinion, is the smoking gun and the main reason (but not only) for the
difference
you are seeing.
Now, the thing your missing in the whole conversation is APRS is the killer
mobile
app that can (and has) brought back packet. As such, our reasons for good
9600bpsperformance are even stronger then before. I think its to everyone's
advantage to
pressure the manufacturers to put out a well performing 9600bps radio, even
though
not many are yet using them on APRS.
And since I am being preachy, in the bigger picture I'd also suggest we use
technology
outside of our domain, when possible. There has been alot of prior art we have
ignored,
as well as things going on today, that might be of benefit to APRS. It is out
there for
the taking.
> Still today, in
> 2000, I do not see 9600 baud in general use in the USA. I think anyone
> should be able to see that point.
Hey, and even I saw your point! I was just questioning your data in this
specificcase, and not your conclusion. Just wanted you to be accurate, even
though your final point was the same. 9600 baud critical mass didn't miss by
much in the
U.S., and with the support of the APRS community, and pressure on the
manufacturers
to put out a good product, it's not to late. Two Kansas companies have put out
decent
data radios (Kantronics with the defunct D4-10, TEKK to this day with the
KS-960) and
if they can do it for $xxx, I don't see why the flashy bell and whistle amateur
radio
companies can't do it at $xxx+.
-Jeff
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: 1200 vs 9600 vs 56000
From: Dale Heatherington <dale@wa4dsy.net>
Date: Mon, 18 Dec 2000 16:08:50 -0500
X-Message-Number: 22
I've not been following this 9600 vs 1200 thread closely
but I'm curious how 9600 compares with 56000.
Below is the test results for my modem. If the
BER for 9600 was posted earlier I missed it.
WA4DSY 56KB RF modem bit error rate test.
Errors counted during 18 seconds (1 million bits)
uV DBM bit error count
0.56 -112 51091
0.63 -111 26073
0.71 -110 8343
0.89 -109 1939
1.0 -108 443
1.1 -107 36
1.2 -106 0
*note: performance degrades about 1 db if the carrier is +/- 5khz off
frequency.
--
Dale Heatherington
dale@wa4dsy.net
Web Page http://www.wa4dsy.net
Sent by KMail for Linux
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: 9600bps radios
From: Mark Fellhauer <sparkfel@primenet.com>
Date: Mon, 18 Dec 2000 15:11:02 -0600
X-Message-Number: 23
At 01:21 PM 12/18/00, Timothy J Salo wrote:
>Well, it may be unlikely, given that we appear to two guys who are neither
>able to let the other have the last word nor able to definitely provide the
>last word themselves.
Which is why I stopped when Stan asked me to. Perhaps we can talk about
Powerpole connectors now. :)
(sorry)
73,
Mark
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: HD-4040 problem
From: Eric Cuthbert <cuthbert@sympatico.ca>
Date: Mon, 18 Dec 2000 16:37:03 -0500
X-Message-Number: 24
Something also has to be said for finding, fixing and resolving ones own
problems. It might be easier to buy or build something new but you will
appreciate your equipment more if you know how to fix or have fixed it
yourself. As well as learn something new. That is part of our hobby!
I think you should fix it first, then if you wish, you could give/sell
it to some deserving ham starting out in Packet Radio for the first
time.
Just an opinion.
-=73=- Eric/va3ewc
Mark Fellhauer wrote:
snip
> Earl, give the 4040 a proper burial or put it in the attic with the Vic
> 20. ;-)
>
> A recent issue of QST had a low cost PIC based Kiss TNC featured in it. It
> might be easier to build something new. Plus the new unit is much much
> smaller and can be powered by a 9 volt battery (if I remember correctly).
>
> 73,
>
> Mark
> KC7BXS
>
> ---
> You are currently subscribed to aprssig as: cuthbert@sympatico.ca
> To unsubscribe send a blank email to leave-aprssig-18700I@lists.tapr.org
> Questions regarding the SIG go to the SIG administrator: wa1lou@tapr.org
--
Where's Eric ?? http://map.findu.com/va3ewc-9
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: 9600 Baud Cxxx
From: Mark Fellhauer <sparkfel@primenet.com>
Date: Mon, 18 Dec 2000 15:36:27 -0600
X-Message-Number: 25
At 02:52 PM 12/18/00, Jeff King wrote:
>Now, the thing your missing in the whole conversation is APRS is the
>killer mobile
>app that can (and has) brought back packet. As such, our reasons for good
>9600bps
>performance are even stronger then before. I think its to everyone's
>advantage to
>pressure the manufacturers to put out a well performing 9600bps radio,
>even though
>not many are yet using them on APRS.
The problem being that current amateur radio 9600 BPS technology (even with
data radios) is not well suited for terrestrial mobile applications. Both
Phil Karn (KA9Q) and Dale Heatherington (WA4DSY) have written about the
severe shortcomings of conventional packet schemes especially when it comes
Read previous mail | Read next mail
| |