OpenBCM V1.13 (Linux)

Packet Radio Mailbox

DB0FHN

[JN59NK Nuernberg]

 Login: GUEST





  
ZL3AI  > APRS     05.11.00 07:40l 200 Lines 7388 Bytes #999 (0) @ WW
BID : 34268_ZL3AI
Read: GUEST
Subj: TAPR Digest, Oct 31, 6/10
Path: DB0MRW<DB0PV<OE2XOM<OE5XBL<OE3XSR<OK0PPL<OK0POK<9A0YRB<HI8GN<KP4IG<
      EA3RKU<EA3CWZ<EA3URS<ZS6RO<ZL3VML
Sent: 001101/1024Z @:ZL3VML.#80.NZL.OC #:45764 [Chch-NZ] FBB7.00g25 $:34268_ZL3
From: ZL3AI@ZL3VML.#80.NZL.OC
To  : APRS@WW


Now it just remains to be seen how popular the Garmin units become!

Mike





----------------------------------------------------------------------

Subject: Re: FSRs and Packet
From: Roger Grady <k9opo@netusa1.net>
Date: Tue, 31 Oct 2000 11:49:34 -0500
X-Message-Number: 23

Maybe I missed it - how does Garmin envision the data their new units
trasnmit will be used? Will their FRS/GPS handhelds be like a FRS-only
-D7A? Is there new software coming also?

Rgoer Grady  K9OPO

----------------------------------------------------------------------

Subject: Re: FSRs and Packet
From: "Smith, Tim" <n1btq@ne.mediaone.net>
Date: Tue, 31 Oct 2000 12:22:24 -0500
X-Message-Number: 24

>>>I think there is a HUGE difference between the two scenarios.

>>>In one case, it's using equipment already built, and having FCC
blessing, to just look at and decode the data they send.

I don't disagree based on the snapshot of the rules today.  It's only a
matter of time before before other manufacturers will want to offer
"modular" appliances to take advantage of the existing installed base of FRS
and similar services (i.e, plugins to FRS such as TNC's, GPS units, DTMF
signalling, remote control, etc.)  With the FCC granting the initial
variance to Garmin I'm sure that others will seek similar variations based
on precedence in due time.  Keep in mind that the rule sets are intended to
govern the content and effect they have on the occupied bandwidth.  If
modular devices have the sane effect on content that the proposed fully
integrated units, to me that's enough to pursue additional variances.

Look at the difference in applications as related to rule sets:  A simple
application of APRS using ham bands to track a boat race somewhat clear for
amusement, safety or civic reasons.  However if a race team wants to track
the same boat for stragetic reasons and is eligable for prize money I'm
afraid that amateur based APRS isn't a good fit.  If you apply the rules to
other services there's probably no clear choices...so most will resort to a
"good, better, best" scenario.  FRS seems to be a more convienant choice.
If not FRS...then other services will have to be examined.

Personally I'm in favor of opening the scope of FRS to include signalling.

Tim




----------------------------------------------------------------------

Subject: Re: FSRs and Packet
From: "Mike Yetsko" <myetsko@insydesw.com>
Date: Tue, 31 Oct 2000 13:38:38 -0500
X-Message-Number: 25

> Personally I'm in favor of opening the scope of FRS to include
signalling.

Hmm, I'm not.

In the very areas where the signaling would be used, it would already
be congested.

FRS is "Family" Radio Service, not Business Radio Service.  And I think
it should be kept that way.  Besides, who in their right mind as a
business
would ever depend on an FRS link, when all kinds of kids or just plain
people who didn't know what it was would be out there listening and
potentially jamming due to frustration.  And if one group in a
competition
tried to use it for a strategic advantage, how many others would?
There's
only 14 channels.  I see it as anarchy real quick.  It's hard enough now
to
go to an 'event' and find a 'clear channel' sometimes.  NO WAY would
I support something like this!!

In the spring of 1999, I was at the NHRA Spring Nationals.  And it was
almost impossible to use FRS there it was so crowded.  There were
people changing CTCSS two and three times a day trying to move
away from others using the same CTCSS.   It truly was a zoo.  And this
was over a year ago and BEFORE FRS became the cheapie $25
toy.  My Maxon units were $180, but usually obtainable for under $100,
and occasionally really discounted to about $60 or so.

ANYONE who advocates a use of FRS like this obviously has never been
in the real world with a crowded event and really played with FRS.

Mike



----------------------------------------------------------------------

Subject: Re: FSRs and Packet
From: "Smith, Tim" <n1btq@ne.mediaone.net>
Date: Tue, 31 Oct 2000 13:04:45 -0500
X-Message-Number: 26

My last thread since it's drifted off sig topic....

Speaking of real world, FRS has already gone beyond a point of no return.
If you drive through any commercial district you will be guarenteed to hear
business traffic....valet parking, restraunt seating, toy stores checking
inventory in the warehouse.  The term "family" does not accurately decribe
the service even thought the name implies otherwise.  I know of deals where
restraunt chains have ordered thousand of FRS radios to use for seating,
check out your local Wal-Mart, K-Mart, Sears...they abandoned itinerant
freqs in favor of the cheapies.  If you speak of anarchy...you're too late
in your prediction...it's here.  Are they legal?  Of course not...is it
enforced?  Hardly.

I think you're upset becasue you dropped $180 for a radio that you thought
would be a quiet haven :-)

Advocacy has nothing to do with it...it's happening now.  You may not like
my opinion on the subject but you can't deny the popularity...for whatever
applications.

As far as signalling goes...look at 27Mhz and 49Mhz r/c.  Opponents said it
will never work but Radio Shack, Tyco, Mattel and others crank them out by
the thousands.  Don't be so narrow-minded about the signalling...it's around
the corner, like it or not.

I have a question...how can you hear your FRS at NHRA?  :-)

Tim


-----Original Message-----
From: Mike Yetsko [mailto:myetsko@insydesw.com]
Sent: Tuesday, October 31, 2000 1:39 PM
To: n1btq@ne.mediaone.net; TAPR APRS Special Interest Group
Subject: Re: [aprssig] Re: FSRs and Packet


> Personally I'm in favor of opening the scope of FRS to include
signalling.

Hmm, I'm not.

In the very areas where the signaling would be used, it would already
be congested.

FRS is "Family" Radio Service, not Business Radio Service.  And I think
it should be kept that way.  Besides, who in their right mind as a
business
would ever depend on an FRS link, when all kinds of kids or just plain
people who didn't know what it was would be out there listening and
potentially jamming due to frustration.  And if one group in a
competition
tried to use it for a strategic advantage, how many others would?
There's
only 14 channels.  I see it as anarchy real quick.  It's hard enough now
to
go to an 'event' and find a 'clear channel' sometimes.  NO WAY would
I support something like this!!

In the spring of 1999, I was at the NHRA Spring Nationals.  And it was
almost impossible to use FRS there it was so crowded.  There were
people changing CTCSS two and three times a day trying to move
away from others using the same CTCSS.   It truly was a zoo.  And this
was over a year ago and BEFORE FRS became the cheapie $25
toy.  My Maxon units were $180, but usually obtainable for under $100,
and occasionally really discounted to about $60 or so.

ANYONE who advocates a use of FRS like this obviously has never been
in the real world with a crowded event and really played with FRS.

Mike


-----Original Message-----
From: bounce-aprssig-17998@lists.tapr.org
[mailto:bounce-aprssig-17998@lists.tapr.org]On Behalf Of Mike Yetsko
Sent: Tuesday, October 31, 2000 1:39 PM
To: TAPR APRS Special Interest Group
Subject: [aprssig] Re: FSRs and Packet




{Mensaje distribuido por: EANET (Gracias U.R.E. por el reglamentazo.)}


Read previous mail | Read next mail


 17.11.2026 04:07:05lGo back Go up