| |
ZL3AI > APRS 02.11.00 09:19l 237 Lines 7787 Bytes #999 (0) @ WW
BID : 34229_ZL3AI
Read: GUEST
Subj: TAPR Digest, Oct 30, 3/8
Path: DB0MRW<DB0ERF<DB0FBB<DB0GOS<DB0PKE<DB0OVN<ON5VL<LX0HST<HA3PG<7M3TJZ<
LZ3NP<ZS6RO<ZL3VML
Sent: 001031/1151Z @:ZL3VML.#80.NZL.OC #:45597 [Chch-NZ] FBB7.00g25 $:34229_ZL3
From: ZL3AI@ZL3VML.#80.NZL.OC
To : APRS@WW
RELAY,WIDE,WIDE is still the best bet for a stand alone tracker.
On 29 Oct 00, at 8:44, Frank Ingle wrote:
> Rather than try to customize your unproto, I would suggest leaving
> it set for RELAY,WIDE2-2. According to the rules, this should work
> as well as anything else.
Rich K4GPS
k4gps@bellsouth.net
Click here to track me: http://map.aprs.net/k4gps
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: FSRs and Packet
From: Bob Bruninga <bruninga@nadn.navy.mil>
Date: Mon, 30 Oct 2000 13:16:01 -0500 (EST)
X-Message-Number: 8
On Mon, 30 Oct 2000, Ralph Milnes wrote:
> I know this was discussed previously on the SIG so I hate to rehash it, but
> would someone like to venture an opinion about whether packet could be used
> on the FRS frequencies.
Garmin has received a ruling that permits them to transmit GPS data on FRS
frequencies as long as the tones are less than 1 sec (If I remember
correctly). Nothing I saw tends to force a particular protocol, and I
assume that if Garmin got the approval, then anyone can do it.
IE, APRS in Mic-Encoder mode where it is an adjunct to voice
communications would appear to me to be legal now?
Bob
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: FSRs and Packet
From: "Mike Yetsko" <myetsko@insydesw.com>
Date: Tue, 31 Oct 2000 01:21:34 -0500
X-Message-Number: 9
One thing I didn't address, but should have...
Yo mentioned getting kids interested in digital modes. Then why
not? It's a great idea, but do it legally, not by bending the rules.
For example, use a laser. Or a remote control. There are a couple
of vendors that make 'light beam communicators' like Ramsey.
You can use them to go audio to light to audio. OR you can use them
to go light to audio to light. The later can be used for extending
remote controls, the former for 'talking' OR feeding the output of a
TNC to it go light, then back to a TNC. Of course, that means line
of sight...
I've also been getting the itch to play with a laser pointer. One
person
told me he's had decent luck with putting an audio transformer in series
with the battery of a cheap pointer and modulating it by just feeding
audio. Wonder how that would work with a TNC driving it...
Hmm, might work better if it used a trick like tape recorders do with a
high frequency bias to ride on...
Hmm....
Mike
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: FSRs and Packet
From: Ralph Milnes <milnes1@rcn.com>
Date: Mon, 30 Oct 2000 13:23:21 -0500
X-Message-Number: 10
Dave and Jeff and others .. thanks. I was looking for some friendly
discussion on this to help me make up my mind.
Dave wrote:
>The intent is obviously to permit PL or selective calling.
>
>Why not use MURS, where digital is specifically permitted ?
>You'll have to wait till Nov 13th, but that's not much of a challenge.
>I hate to see newcomers taught to bend the rules.
Well, I don't want to bend the rules either, but I'm not sure it's bending.
All we have to go on is the language in the rules.
One could argue that #1. (b) simply modifies (a). (i.e. voice with
tones); or # 2. one could argue that (b) is independent of (a) (i,e. voice
*or* tones
I'd argue that you can't assume premise #1 based on the language in the
reg. I say any intent or implication that (b) modifies (a) is not in
writing... it's just not there.
I don't want to play attorney on this and I know each side has a reasonably
argument so ..
I could ask the FCC for a clarification (no, thank you) .. or I could just
go ahead and do it.
But I won't if I sense the consensus is that I'm *clearly* in violation of
the reg.
That being said, let me turn the question away from "what you think the FCC
meant?" (Dave may be right) to "Do you think an operator can find in the
law a basis for operating packet on the FSR frequencies?"
And, Dave, the FSRs are readily available for kids. I'm assuming MURS
capable radios are not, right?
Ralph
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: FSRs and Packet
From: Ralph Milnes <milnes1@rcn.com>
Date: Mon, 30 Oct 2000 13:34:02 -0500
X-Message-Number: 11
Mike wrote:
>I think the phrase:
>
> "The FRS unit may transmit tones to make contact or to continue
> communications with a particular FRS unit. "
>
>is fairly descriptive. Prior to this is explicitly says voice. Here it
>does NOT say voice, but it explicitly says:
>
> "to make contact or to continue communications"
To me, it's the definition of packet.
>Besides, isn't that just what HAM radio needs for it's image? The big
>powerful HAM coming down to FRS and taking what are already
>limited resources there.
Wait a minute. My intent was to have non-licensed kids use the frequency.
In fact, I agree with you hams don't need to use the FSR for packet.
And the tie-in to APRS on this discussion -- hypothetically FSRs could be
used for APRS by non-hams --say on balloons.
Ralph, KC2RLM
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: FSRs and Packet
From: David VanHorn <dvanhorn@cedar.net>
Date: Mon, 30 Oct 2000 13:47:58 -0500
X-Message-Number: 12
>
>Wait a minute. My intent was to have non-licensed kids use the frequency.
>In fact, I agree with you hams don't need to use the FSR for packet.
Nothing prevents you from using dummy loads, and working short distances
under part 15 either..
Bob brought up an interesting point, apparently Garmin has an OK to do
something very similar to APRS, with a time limit on the packet. Sounds
like they were more permissive than I thought they would be.
I drive like that too.. I'm the guy doing 45 in the construction zone
that's marked with big "45 MPH" signs.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: FSRs and Packet
From: Bob Bruninga <bruninga@nadn.navy.mil>
Date: Mon, 30 Oct 2000 13:53:31 -0500 (EST)
X-Message-Number: 13
On Mon, 30 Oct 2000, Ralph Milnes wrote:
> And the tie-in to APRS on this discussion -- hypothetically FSRs could be
> used for APRS by non-hams --say on balloons.
WOOAHA..<grin> well, I think that would not be a friendly thing to do,
wiping out FRS over a 3 state area. That would insure that the FCC would
squelch this concept immediately...
Garmin got a rulling that GPS data couild be added to facilitate human to
human communications by including informaiton about where the person is.
That seems to fit within the intent of FRS. Using FRS for
conventional packet does not fit within the "intent" of FRS in my opinion.
I think in reading of "rulings" common sense is supposed to generally
apply..
You can imagine the daggers I caught in the AMSAT Brainstorming session
when I proposed an FRS AMSAT. It would have a power such that it COULD
NOT BE HEARD ON THE GROUND BY ANY FRS radio. THus it could NOT intefere
with ANY terrestrial use of FRS... But if an unmodified fully legal FRS
radio was placed at the focal point of a chicken wire dish of a few feet
diameter, then it could be heard. and then the satellite could hear it.
Thus an EMERGECNY FRS SAR SATELLITE for unlicensed ops and AMSAT could
take credit for it. THe idea was to explore ways to reach out to techies
that were not necessarily hams in the first place.
I was shot down in flames... hi hi...
de WB4APR, Bob
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: European packet(was thanks for the post).
From: Jeff King <jeff@aerodata.net>
Date: Mon, 30 Oct 2000 14:04:33 -0500
X-Message-Number: 14
Henk:
The most interesting thing about your post was the complete silence it provoked
Read previous mail | Read next mail
| |