| |
DK8KV > QRP 19.02.00 08:22l 81 Lines 3901 Bytes #-9767 (0) @ EU
BID : J20DB0MKA01J
Read: DL3GRE DL2MHG GUEST
Subj: Elecraft K2 vs. others RX-perf.
Path: DB0ZKA<DB0CRL<DB0TTM<DB0FP<DB0SRS<DB0ZDF<DB0LJ<DB0MKA
Sent: 000219/0700z @:DB0MKA.#NRW.DEU.EU [HennefJO30PR DL3OE] DB19c1 $:J20DB0MKA
From: DK8KV @ DB0MKA.#NRW.DEU.EU (Walter)
To: QRP @ EU
Here are ARRL's RX performance numbers, published on Elecraft web
page. After I noticed bad noise blanker IMD performance in January
Elecraft fixed the problem immediately. IP3-Measurements were made
showing much better performance than expected.
K2 RX Performance Comparisons 2/18/2000
-----------------------------
All of the test numbers listed below are from the ARRL reviews for each rig.
(See below for descriptions of each test and links to QST articles about
these tests.)
These results and may vary a few DB from rig to rig. These numbers are for
14Mhz operation, 500 Hz CW filter, AGC off, High Ip mode.
XX / YY = preamp-off / preamp-on
RIG MDS(dBm) IMDDR3(dB) Ip3(dBm) Ip2(dBm) BDR(dB)
--------------------------------------------------------------------
K2 -131/-138 97/98 +21.6/+6.9 +76/+75 136/128
Ten-Tec Omni6+ -133 97 +12 +58 123 (nl)
FT-1000MP -128/-135 97/94 +15/+5 +86/+88 142/137
TS-870 -129/-139 97/95 +16/+4 +63/+63 127/123
Kachina 505DSP -133/-142 99/97 +15.5/+3.5 +49/+30 103/103
Pegasus 550DSP -132 77 +7.2 +44.3 110(nl)
IC-706MKIIG -136/-142 89/86 -1.3/-11 +36.4/+38.5 122(nl)/120(nl)
TS-50 -132/-139 90/88 +3/-7 not meas. 113/109
Ten-Tec Scout -125 87 +5.5 not meas. 119
SGC-2020 -130 88 +15.5 +32 110 (nl)
nl = test was noise limited (noise floor rose 1db before 1db of blocking
desense occurred)
MDS = Minimum Discernible Signal (3db increase above noise floor).
Larger negative numbers are generally better, but too much
sensitivity can reduce strong signal dynamic range and Ip3. Pre-Amp
On MDS numbers of -134dBm or more are more than adequate for most HF
band operating, since band noise is typically above this number.
(Lower frequencies need less MDS (more +number) due to an increase in
atmospheric noise.)
IMDDR3 = 2 tone (20 kHz spacing) 3rd order Two tone IMD Dynamic Range.
This test shows how the RX performs in the presence of multiple
strong nearby signals in relation to its sensitivity (MDS). Higher
is better. Pre-Amp Off IMDDR3 numbers of +95dBm or more are
considered excellent.
Ip3 = 2 tone (20 kHz spacing) 3rd order Intercept Point. This test also
shows how the RX performs in the presence of multiple strong nearby
signals. Higher is better. Pre-Amp OFF IP3 numbers of +15dBm are
good, and +20dBm or more is excellent.
Ip2 = 2 tone (8.020MHz, 6.000MHz) 2nd order Intercept Point This test shows
how the RX performs in the presence of multiple strong out of
band signals (such as broadcast signals on 6Mhz and 8Mhz creating
birdies at 14Mhz). Higher is better. A Pre-Amp OFF IP2 of +50dBm is
good, and +70dBm or more is considered excellent.
BDR = Blocking Dynamic Range (20 kHz spacing). This test shows when the
receiver's sensitivity begins to drop in the presence of strong
near by signals. (Desense). A Pre-Amp OFF BDR of greater than 120dBm
is good. Greater than 130dBm is considered excellent.
Additional descriptions of what these numbers mean and how you can evaluate
a rig can be found on the ARRL web site at the following links:
QST Product Reviews: A Look Behind The Scenes (917,504 bytes, PDF file)
Learn how the ARRL Laboratory evaluates new products - and what all
those numbers mean to you!
Lab Notes - What Rig Should I Buy? (360,448 bytes, PDF file)
ARRL Results are from QST rig reviews (K2, 3/00; Omni6+, 11/97; FT1000MP,
4/96; Scout, 12/93; TS-50, 9/93; SGC-2020, 10/98; IC706MKII, 7/99; Ten Tec
Pegasus, 2/00; Kachina 505DSP, 5/98)
Read previous mail | Read next mail
| |