OpenBCM V1.13 (Linux)

Packet Radio Mailbox

DB0FHN

[JN59NK Nuernberg]

 Login: GUEST





  
PD0RDD > NASA     02.08.98 15:06l 119 Lines 5777 Bytes #-10338 (0) @ WW
BID : 60310_PI8WNO
Read: GUEST
Subj: Nasa Info 066
Path: DB0AAB<DB0AHO<DB0KFB<DB0CZ<DB0GE<DB0IZ<DB0RWI<PI8JOP<PI8ZAA<PI8GCB<
      PI8WNO
Sent: 980802/0946Z @:PI8WNO.#UTR.NLD.EU #:60310 [DeMeern] FBB5.15c $:60310_PI8W
From: PD0RDD@PI8WNO.#UTR.NLD.EU
To  : NASA@WW

Onderwerp:  Lewis Spacecraft Failure Board Report Released
Douglas Isbell
Headquarters, Washington, DC          June 23, 1998
(Phone: 202/358-1753)

RELEASE: 98-109

LEWIS SPACECRAFT FAILURE BOARD REPORT RELEASED

     NASA's Earth-orbiting Lewis spacecraft failed last fall 
due to a combination of a technically flawed attitude-control 
system design and inadequate monitoring of the spacecraft 
during its crucial early operations phase, according to the 
report of the Lewis Spacecraft Mission Failure Investigation Board.

     Lewis was launched on August 23, 1997, with the goal of 
demonstrating advanced science instruments and spacecraft 
technologies for measuring changes in Earth's land surfaces.  
The spacecraft entered a flat spin in orbit that resulted in 
a loss of solar power and a fatal battery discharge.  Contact 
with the spacecraft was lost on Aug. 26, and it then re-
entered the atmosphere and was destroyed on Sept. 28.  The 
890-pound spacecraft was designed and built by TRW Space & 
Electronics Group, Redondo Beach, CA, as part of NASA's Small 
Spacecraft Technology Initiative.

     The design of the Lewis attitude control system was 
adapted by TRW from its design for the system on the Total 
Ozone Mapping Spectrometer spacecraft.  The failure board 
found that this adaptation was done without sufficient 
consideration for applying the system's design to a different 
primary spacecraft spin-axis orientation on Lewis.  As a 
result, minor rotational perturbations, possibly due to small 
imbalances in the forces produced by the spacecraft's 
attitude control thrusters, caused the Lewis spacecraft to 
enter a spin.  This situation eventually overloaded the 
spacecraft's control system while it was in a safehold mode.  
Prelaunch simulation and testing of the spacecraft's safehold 
modes also was flawed because it failed to analyze this 
possibility, the failure board found.  

     The combination of these errors with the subsequent 
assumption that a small crew could monitor and operate Lewis 
with the aid of an autonomous safehold mode, even during the 
initial operations period, was the primary cause of the 
mission failure, according to the failure board's report.

     The failure board also assessed the role of the "faster, 
better, cheaper" project management approach in the Lewis program.

     "The Lewis mission was a bold attempt by NASA to 
jumpstart the application of the 'faster, better, and 
cheaper' philosophy of doing its business," said Christine 
Anderson, chair of the failure board and Director of Space 
Vehicles for the U.S. Air Force Research Laboratory at 
Kirtland Air Force Base, NM.  "I do not think that this 
concept is flawed.  What was flawed in the Lewis program, 
beyond some engineering assumptions, was the lack of clear 
understanding between NASA and TRW about how to apply this 
philosophy effectively.  This includes developing an 
appropriate balance between the three elements of this 
philosophy, the need for well-defined, well-understood and 
consistent roles for government and industry partners, and 
regular communication between all parts of the team."

     "The Lewis failure offers us some valuable lessons in 
program management and in our approach to technical 
'insight.'  Lewis was an extreme example of allowing the 
contractor to have engineering autonomy.  In the end, 
however, NASA has the responsibility to assure that the 
project objectives are met, and our assurance process was 
ineffective in this case," said Dr. Ghassem Asrar, NASA 
Associate Administrator for Earth Science.  "NASA's Office of 
the Chief Engineer is developing general 'lessons learned' 
from this project and other 'faster, better, cheaper' 
efforts, and we intend to apply them vigorously to all of our 
future missions, including the second generation of 
spacecraft in the Earth Observing System.

     "I would like to commend Christine Anderson and the 
members of her panel for their thorough job, and thank all 
the participants in the Lewis program for their cooperation 
with this review," Asrar added.

     The total cost to NASA of the Lewis mission, including 
its launch vehicle and one year of planned orbital 
operations, was $64.8 million.  NASA incurred an additional 
cost of $6.2 million for storage and maintenance of the 
spacecraft during a one-year delay due to launch vehicle issues.

     Lewis was part of NASA's Earth Science enterprise, a 
long-term research program designed to study the Earth's 
land, oceans, air, ice and life as a total system. 

                            -end-

EDITOR'S NOTE: The report of the Lewis Spacecraft Mission 
Failure Investigation Board is available via the Internet at 
the following address:  

   http://arioch.gsfc.nasa.gov/300/html/lewis_document.pdf

                                                     .   
    Greetings from Hans at Maarssenbroek             ³~      The Netherlands
    HomebBs   : PI8WNO                               ×    .
    E-Mail    : pd0rdd@hj-lammers.demon.nl          ×××¶ Úп   
    Home Page : http://www.hj-lammers.demon.nl    Ç××××¶ÚÏÍÏ¿
                                   .       ______ Ç××××¶³###³
    Syteem : Pentium 75            Ø   ÚÄÄÄÊÊÊÊÊÊ¿Ç××××¶³###³       .
    Modem  : Tnc2nl            .  Öη  ³ððððððððð³Ç××××¶³###³°°     ³~
    Progr  : Sp 9.75           ³~ÖÊÊÊ· ³ððððððððð³Ç××××¶³###³°°     ³    .
    Tx/Rx  : Kenwood TS-811e   ³ÖÎÎÎÎη³ððððð²ß²ß²ß²ß²ß²ß²##³°ÛÛÛÛݳ³    ³~
    Freq   : 430.800       ܱ²Ü²ºãããã㺳ðððððºþÜþÜþÜþÜþÜþº##³°ÝÝÝÝÝ۲ܲ³Ü³Ü
                           ÛÛ²²±ººººººº³ððððÖÒÒÒÒÒÒ·þÜþÜþº##³°ÛÞÞÞݱ²²ÛÛ²²Û²Û²Ü
                           ----------------------------------------------------


Read previous mail | Read next mail


 21.11.2026 21:50:13lGo back Go up