| |
G4EBT > DESERT 08.03.03 17:01l 150 Lines 5894 Bytes #999 (0) @ WW
BID : 360742G4EBT
Read: DB0FHN GUEST
Subj: Re: Australia's deserts.
Path: DB0FHN<DB0RGB<OE5XBL<OE3XSR<OK0PBX<OK0PHL<OK0PPR<OK0PPL<RZ6HXA<SP7MGD<
GB7FCR
Sent: 030307/1915Z @:GB7FCR.#16.GBR.EU #:49590 [Blackpool] FBB-7.03a $:360742G4
From: G4EBT@GB7FCR.#16.GBR.EU
To : DESERT@WW
VK6BE, (belligerent Bob), wrote:-
> Thank you David, this is what I have been trying to get over to you
> guys for some time. Thank you.
The main focus of your assertions concerned the word "desert". I think
you said "What is a desert?" Several people have gone to some lengths to
explain, and have confirmed that the majority of Australia's land mass is
classed as desert. You saw it as a slight that the majority of Australia
is desert, and is shown as such on the maps. No-one said it's covered in
sand dunes. Neither has anyone contradicted that vast coastal areas are
scenic, fertile, have a very agreeable climate, and many vibrant towns
and cities.
Right at the outset, you said:
> "It has some desert country yes, but it also has forest areas, snow
> country, and the climate varies from cool temperate to tropical
> grasslands in the north west, and tropical forests in the north east.
> The climate in the north is monsoonal, and most of the south is
> mediterranean".
To say "it has some desert country, yes" plays down the fact the great
deserts cover some 70% of the land mass, and anyone who read the above
statement would get a very misleading picture overall. Odd that you should
leave out the vast desert areas to the west.
The term "desert" has been defined on here several times, in several
excellent and informative bulletins, including some from VK's. If
you've taken note of them, by now you should have a more balanced
perception of what a "dessert" consists of.
> As for the rest, again you are relying on what you read in various
> books,
I've found books to be a much more reliable source than some of the stuff
I've read on packet from some sources. Books on geography, demographics,
and climate aren't works of fiction, they contain factual data. Australia
is of great interest to geographers, and those interested in geography,
and has been well researched and documented.
> I live here which gives me a big advantage over you.
It should be, but seems not to be. Living in Australia has not proved
to be an advantage in terms of your amateur radio regs. According to
your interpretation of your regs, discussing the topics of "Desert"
puts you in breach of your licence. You say there's a list of "suitable
topics". I can't see this topics in the regs. Just as well that there
isn't a list, except in your head.
> Just a final comment on this discussion before I leave it forever.
You'll be back.
> Yes I too am giving it up for Lent.
Good - others who might wish to continue to contribute to it can now do so
without it being yet one more thing for you to get steamed-up and grumpy
about.
> It has gone nowhere.
If by "going nowhere" you mean no-one has come round to your way of
thinking, you may be right, but actually, it's resulted in a lively and
well-informed debate. Those interested in the topic have gone to some
lengths to read up on it, and have contributed some very interesting
bulletins.
> parts of Australia in some places would have temperatures in
> excess of 50C in summer , but noone goes there.
That's precisely the point. They don't go there because it's desert.
> Parts of southern USA are far worse, and so would be parts of
> India and Africa, and the Middle East.
And your point is?
This debate started because some hapless amateur from NL made an innocuous
comment about Australia having lots of areas of desert. You disagreed, and
your response painted a very unbalanced picture, which seems to have acted
as a catalyst to stimulate many others to join in. No bad thing.
> Why pick on us?
Why do you think people are "picking on you"? Most of the stuff I've read
on this topic has been well informed, well researched, and taken together,
has produced a balanced picture of Australia. Nothing wrong with that is
there? If people try to correct your misleading comments, they're trying
to be helpful, and balancing the debate, not "picking on you".
> OK this debate has gone far enough. I have better things to do.
Books to read? Maps to study?
> David and Andy, why don't you pay us a visit?
Why would we want to - it would only verify what we already know? Why not
extend the invitation to everyone - dozens have contributed to the debate,
some several times, not just me and Andy. I've sent one bulletin to date,
this is my second.
> You would get the surprise of your life, and maybe your concept of what
> Australia is like would get a very rude awakening.
I've already got quite an accurate picture of what it's like.
> "Read some books" says David. No, David, books are written by people
> who give their own impressions, often just their own opinion, sometimes
> well informed, sometimes not.
We aren't talking about works of fiction, or holiday brochures, but
academic text books and atlases. To suggest that factual information
recorded over decades as to climate, topography and demography is
"their own impressions and opinions" is too silly for words.
I'm puzzled as to why you would re-transmit the text below. Are you
saying it isn't factual? It was taken from a geography text book.
> > Despite its great deserts, the country has vast areas of fertile well
> > watered land. From east to west, there is a narrow strip of fertile
> > coastland, beyond which mountain ranges reach from Melbourne in the
> > south, right up to Cape York peninsula in the north.
> > These mountains - the Great Dividing Range, form a natural division
> > between the coastland and a fertile tableland, which is flanked on
> > the west by a fertile inland plain.
Regards,
73 - David, G4EBT @ GB7FCR
Eddystone User Group Member
G-QRP Club Member No: 1339
QTH: Cottingham, East Yorkshire.
david@crofters89.freeserve.co.uk
Message timed: 19:05 on 2003-Mar-07
Message sent using WinPack-Telnet V6.70
(Registered).
Read previous mail | Read next mail
| |